Appeal Levels

Appeal levels are the successive stages of disputing a denial — typically two internal levels then an external review for commercial plans, and a fixed five-level ladder for Medicare fee-for-service.

Appeal levels are the ordered stages you move a denied claim through when the payer won't pay. Commercial plans generally have two internal appeal levels — a first-level reconsideration and a second-level appeal — followed, for ACA-regulated plans, by an external independent review. Medicare fee-for-service has a fixed five-level ladder set in federal regulation: redetermination (MAC), reconsideration (QIC), ALJ hearing, Appeals Council review, and federal court, with exact deadlines at each step and dollar thresholds at the higher levels. Medicare Advantage runs on its own plan-based process, not the FFS ladder. Two things make appeal levels matter operationally. First, each level has its own deadline, and missing an early one usually forfeits the rest — the first-level window is the one most often missed because practices treat the initial remit as final. Second, you should build your strongest evidentiary case early, at the first internal level or the Medicare reconsideration, because later levels largely review the record you already submitted rather than accepting new arguments fresh. Knowing the correct level and deadline for each denial — which vary by payer and line of business — is what keeps a winnable claim moving up the ladder instead of expiring at the first step.

See what these terms are costing you.

A free assessment shows your real recoverable number from denials and underpayments. No risk, paid only on what we recover.